A ventilator crisis may loom for Louisiana, but it
is manageable with a bit of forethought.
This device aids, if not entirely performs, breathing
for individuals. A few people (like, for over 17 years, my wife) live with them
permanently, but now demand for these has surged with the Wuhan coronavirus
invasion. In fact, according
to Democrat Gov. John
Bel Edwards, within two weeks the state health region (One) serving Orleans
Parish will exhaust its supply of this equipment.
Keep in mind that Region One is not just the
epicenter of the virus infection for Louisiana, but vying for that sad
designation in the entire country. Orleans, Jefferson, Plaquemines, and St. Bernard
Parishes had 65 percent of the
state’s cases as of today, and the region’s incidence rate of under one in
every 600 residents nationally trails only the New
York City area. The Orleans rate of 1:393 is slightly higher than New York
City’s, but New York’s Nassau County’s is a bit higher and Westchester’s unbelievably
is more than twice as high.
So, what are Louisianan’s options as the economic
impact of the Wuhan coronavirus continues to linger?
It all starts with the Revenue Estimating
Conference, which last year made forecasts for fiscal year 2021 that the
Democrat Gov. John
Bel Edwards Administration wanted to bump up two months ago. Leery (presciently)
of the state’s economic health, Republican leaders of the Legislature didn’t
want to commit to a $100 million or so boost and no
change occurred.
Chances are, with the price
of oil more than halved in just weeks, taxes on sales, income, and gambling
likely to feel ongoing effects from what appears to be a month-long economic
moratorium, and the decline in investments that will force the state to commit
more current revenues to shore up its unfunded accrued liabilities, that
supposed surplus more than has disappeared. This means cuts for FY 2021, unless
bringing into play the Budget
Stabilization Fund.
There’s no “nuance”
in Democrat Gov. John
Bel Edwards’ dictionary, but “fear” is a word prominently displayed when it comes to the current pandemic.
Sunday, Edwards
issued another proclamation
regarding the advance of the Wuhan coronavirus in Louisiana. This one now limits
gatherings to ten and closed additional businesses, allowing open only grocery
stores, pharmacies, medical facilities, factories, transportation hubs, and
critical infrastructure, although a social distancing limit is asked to be observed.
People also are advised not to leave homes unless to shop for groceries, seek
medical supplies or care, or go to work if part of the businesses not closed or
not involved with public interaction.
The announcement he made to accompany that
highlighted the per
capita incidence and rate of growth of cases in Louisiana. As of Sunday
morning, the state had the third highest per capita infection rate of
the states, trailing only the epicenter Washington and hard-hit New York. It
also in its first 13 days since the initial reported infection had the most severe
growth rate of any country or state, with a current trend well above the average.
Almost the only live sport to remain over the past
couple of weeks since professional leagues and college associations cancelled
their remaining seasons has been horse racing. Unfortunately, despite its
prevalence in Louisiana, it won’t help the looming budget crisis to come and the
fallout may put the industry closer to extinction in the state.
With voluntary slowdowns and a succession of
proclamations by Democrat Gov. John Bel Edwards, a sizable portion of economic
activity within the state’s borders has come to a halt. Combine that with
downturns in the oil and equity markets, and the recipe for a budget shortfall
for this year plus carryover into next fiscal year’s if not a matter of if, but
how much.
Suspension of athletic events contributes to this,
in the form of taxes gathered on lost ticket and concession sales, as well as
income taxes forgone from athletes not receiving pay (both residents and
non-residents). However, horse
racing kept on, with New Orleans’ Fair Grounds continuing its thoroughbred
meet and Bossier City’s Louisiana Downs its quarter horse meet. They did so,
after the Edwards bans on more than 250 (later lowered to 50) people gathering,
by barring spectators.
In
Louisiana’s response to the Wuhan coronavirus pandemic, policy-makers must
keep in mind that not only is it essentially a New Orleans-area problem, but
that in per capita terms New Orleans right now is one of the world’s
most dangerous hotspots for the disease.
While some elected officials have highlighted
Louisiana’s incidence as something like one of the three highest per capita
states, most have missed the fact that Orleans Parish has the second-highest
rate per capita of any metropolitan county in the country. As of this morning, an
astonishing 1 in fewer than 1,700 Orleanians have or had the virus. Extrapolate
this nationwide and that would indicate over 193,000 cases when in fact the U.S.
has reported only 10,442, and worldwide
outside the U.S. the number is about 226,000.
King County, the location
of Seattle, WA has drawn the most attention since the virus appeared there first
in the U.S. But its incidence ratio is twice as high as Orleans’. The only ratio
lower has appeared in Westchester
County, NY: with about a million people, it has nearly 800 cases.
At least in one respect business as usual goes on
with Louisiana’s Board of Elementary and
Secondary Education: selecting a new
permanent leader.
Recently, the Board
proposed a slew of measures related to the closure of schools for a month by
Democrat Gov. John
Bel Edwards last week. Essentially, these dismantle all accountability measures
for students, educators, schools, and districts. Ironically, this bow to
reality for this academic year creates an environment close to what Edwards
would want in regards to the issue of accountability, so he will issue the
necessary proclamations with relish.
But Edwards, his teacher union allies, and many on
the political left would like to see more than just a temporary acceptance of
this agenda thrust upon the state by fate, and going beyond that begin with
appointing a new state superintendent sympathetic to their views. Longtime
superintendent John White – who very much supported an accountability agenda
the opposite of Edwards and these others – exited last week, and BESE has begun
the process of finding his replacement.
Never let a crisis go to waste: Democrat Gov. John Bel Edwards may
wish to see the 2020 Regular Session of the Louisiana Legislature do as little
as possible, and he’s found the circumstance to prompt that.
His latest proclamation dealing with the Wuhan
coronavirus until Apr. 13 limits gatherings to 50 people, which undercuts the
House of Representatives and its 144 members plus staff. It also puts on the
rivet the 39-member Senate, when including staff. Worse for legislators, access
to bars and restaurants is cut off except for take-out and delivery of food. Leaders decided to
halt proceedings for at least two weeks.
Such a draconian response by Edwards might be necessary for the health and general public as a whole, but it serves a political
purpose as well. On its present trajectory, the Legislature is poised to hand
Edwards some significant defeats while little of his agenda has any
chance of coming to fruition.