Would it be so bad if Gov. Bobby
Jindal on his quixotic quest to eliminate Louisiana’s participation in the
Common Core State Standards would just simply declare victory?
He specifically, but including as
fellow travelers a few legislators, a couple of members of the Board of
Elementary and Secondary Education, and many union officials, suffered
a defeat at the hands of 19th District Court Judge Todd
Hernandez when the jurist agreed
with plaintiffs enjoining enforcement of Republican Jindal’s two recent
executive orders that had the practical effect of greatly interfering with administration
of tests in a few months aligned with the Common Core State Standards. They
argued that these orders could not apply because there was no evidence of
wrongdoing in contracting for the exams and thus over this aspect of
educational policy otherwise Jindal’s Division of Administration had no authority.
Hernandez wrote that any trial following the injunction would be likely to go
the plaintiffs’ way.
Superintendent of Education John
White said that, with certainty seemingly assured over testing now, the harm of
lack of ability to know for which kind of assessment to prepare, the results of
which have many consequences such as in teacher evaluations and school
accountability, was negated and use
of these tests would be scheduled. The governor’s office vowed to appeal,
bitterly complaining that the court took the plaintiffs’ argument “hook, line
and sinker.”