Call it the Ganja Gambit – a last-second desperation attempt to sway anti-tax Republican legislators to make permanent a 0.45 percent sales tax increase.
This week, Republican state Rep. Tanner Magee’s HB 391 won legislative approval and now heads to Democrat Gov. John Bel Edwards who has said he’ll sign it into law. It creates an extraordinarily relaxed process that allows members of the public to get their hands on over a hundred joints a week ostensibly for medical reasons so open-ended that in short order some doctor somewhere will “recommend” it for halitosis.
Don’t expect all the “patients” to sit tight on their stashes. Unused portions will filter out onto the street for those willing to pay more for less bureaucracy to get high. Watch over the coming years the state’s two producers, allied with two of its university systems, ramp up production to meet this demand (and they’ll get a piece of the increased action as well).
But to the societal madness Magee presents fiscal method, because his HB 514, coming up for Senate approval after radical changes, would try to capture government revenue from the predictable upswing in weed consumption. That bill applies the state’s 4.45 percent sales tax to currently untaxed medical marijuana sales ad infinitum.
To infinity, because the bill also prevents 0.45 percent of that tax, first imposed in 2016 and reimposed in 2018 until 2025, from rolling off as scheduled. The avails from that would go mostly to roads construction, although half of the amount collected on medically-authorized spliff would head to funding early childhood education and public defense, two expenditure areas chronically short on stable revenue.
No doubt that diversion is designed to suck in votes from tax-leery legislators cognizant that keeping the tax on the books separates the people from more than $400 million a year of their money. Since they already have agreed to backdoor legalization of smoking dope, the consolation would be that increase would help out funding these two functions, as well as throw money at – without insisting on reforms that could result in over $100 million a year in additional infrastructure money – working down a roads backlog.
In short, while more fiscally responsible legislators, and/or those who don’t like regressive taxation, might balk at making the tax increase permanent if it only addresses roads, the deal could become amenable to them if it also tries to cover the two other policy areas. As the matter will need at least two supermajority votes to pass – on the Senate floor (where it already achieved that when Magee Senate allies needed approval to slap on the roads component onto the original lid taxation) and for House concurrence – if not at least one more because its late arrival in the House likely means a supermajority vote to put it on the agenda, a lot of anti-tax legislators would have needed to find this inducement attractive to pick up their votes.
However, they didn’t bite. The new House Louisiana Conservative Caucus – a group of 41 of the 68 chamber Republicans who pointedly have kept Magee and his allied excluded – has announced its members oppose the bill, and some Democrats who oppose regressive taxes should join them in this. With all of the supermajority hurdles in place, the bill seems unlikely to progress.
If so, Magee’s attempt to expand permanently government will fail (unless he submits to reality and gets the Senate to yank the permanent increase on the floor, which many GOP senators will want in order to cancel their initial approval of embedding the hike) and not even leave available a revenue stream from all that extra grass, the consumption of which could have distracted some of the public from realizing their sales taxes would go up from 2025 onwards. Regardless, the permanently increased drug use and its consequences from the faulty decision to pass HB 391 will remain.