It always was going to come to this with Shreveport’s venture into venture capitalism, and it’s worse than you think.
Another projected shortfall this year and projected for next will leave the total deficit since its opening at $23.8 million of taxpayer subsidies. The debt to pay for it still has about $25 million to run and won’t be paid off until 2035, and Dark admits the gap will grow throughout.
By the book, the proprietary fund at the end of 2025 had a deficit of $3.4 million. However, in a version of we-owe-it-to-ourself, Dark waved off worry about that balance in the red, calling it a “paper deficit” and saying that “[y]ou can't have a good convention center without a headquarters hotel.”
That attitude is exactly the problem, which Dark should remember as the city under Democrat Mayor Keith Hightower – leading to the satirical name given to the hotel the “Hightower Hilton” (Hilton, because the city contracts out its operation to that firm) – was warned repeatedly despite a campaign of his blowing sunshine up skirts that it would make money that the economics didn’t support that fantasy. The liberals that ran the city at that time preached about spending more money and on pie-in-the-sky silver bullets to spur economic development and arrest the city’s population decline, which now approaches 22 percent since 1970, such as the pipe dream of a convention center and attached hotel helping to come to the rescue.
And even Dark’s trying to put a happy face on the white elephant falls flat when reviewing the record. The hotel did operationally make money in 2025, as well as in the previous two years – but prior to that lost around $8 million since 2015.Given that history, there’s no guarantee that “profits” will continue.
Yet this isn’t even the worst of it. Dark is right, the hotel needs to be viewed in the context of the Center, in part its financial performance. And that’s even more injurious to the taxpayer.
Unlike the hotel, the Center had its debt paid off years ago, through revenue bonds attached to casino earnings (as well as the state kicking in some money) – in other words, money that could have gone to more useful capital outlay projects. Yet its operational deficit dwarfs that of the hotel; since 2015 it has lost consistently every year and in aggregate put taxpayers $42 million in the hole.
Of course, as Dark pointed out, spillover revenues will accrue from the hotel. Let’s assume all rooms rented, about 90,000 nights’ worth in recent years, are for conventions, and further assume they price at $100 a night. Given the 6.1 percent sales plus hotel occupancy tax, that’s about $550,000 in revenue collection for the city annually. That’s not even close to paying the combined at present $5.8 million annual deficit for the Center and hotel. And you’d have to generate about $114 million worth of sales tax revenue from other sources such as from food and drink – or, if using the assumption of 90,000 room-nights spending $1,268 a night per room – to make up that deficit, which clearly is unrealistic.
But what’s to say you even needed the hotel? The nearby casinos have large ones, and a few others are within easy walking distance. Although even if you absolutely needed one connected to the Center, why couldn’t the private sector provide it? Dark mentioned a sale of the hotel never materialized as its debt is higher than its actual market value.
There’s a reason for that: almost no convention centers generate enough direct and indirect revenues to cover their costs and changing economics make it an increasingly difficult proposition. To try to counter this demands an arms race to more money spent which Shreveport can ill afford, especially with an expiring consent decree for water and sewerage provision still hanging over the city’s head that will cost hundreds of millions of more dollars to fulfill.
Shreveporters have been fleeced royally by this get-rich-quick scheme engineered by politicians more eager to look like bigshots than willing to do the hard work of budget- and tax-cutting to make the city a more desirable place to live. The hotel must be sold off as soon as financially possible, and the convention center turned into something more practical (instead of taking a chance with the G-Dome?).
No comments:
Post a Comment